It’s 7:39 am, which is not that early in the grand scheme of things. In some interesting twist of the clock, my older children chose to sleep in just a little later than usual.

The baby was up at 4 o’clock for her morning feed, but she is the easiest kid on my radar these days. Eat, poop, coo, snuggle, sleep and start the cycle over. This third iteration of motherhood means that I have babies down to something of a loose science, an expected rhythm.

It’s her four-and-a-half-year-old sister, struggling with jealousy and growing pains, and her two-and-a-half-year-old brother, learning to use the potty on his own, who leave me and my husband spent. The unpredictable extra bit of sleep they need in the morning is generally welcome; one less minute in which our minds are engaged in anticipating the next fire that may need to be put out.

But of course today, as Murphy’s Law would have it, we actually have some plans which will require our eyes to fixate on the clock a little more than usual. Early rising may actually have been helpful so as to avoid the ticking time bomb known as rushing your kids out the door.

Once they’re up, I hurriedly pour Cheerios in cheerfully colored plastic bowls and run back to the refrigerator for the milk which I pour carefully so as to not nudge Cheerios out of the bowl. My older two sit down to eat just as the baby gets fussy for second breakfast. I scoop her out of her bouncy seat and head to the couch in the living room to cuddle and nurse her while I have the time, out of eyesight of the older two. I’m thankful for an excuse to sit down.

“Mama, I made a spill,” I hear my daughter say calmly about a minute later.

“Ok, just a minute,” I respond. I can’t see it, but it’s probably just a spoonful that fell onto the table or the floor. I’d have her clean it up but I don’t have the time this morning to wait patiently through her cleaning process.

The baby seems satisfied enough so I slip her off my breast and head to take a look at the damage. As I turn the corner, I have to search for the spill: it’s not on the table, nor on the floor. No, this time, the bowl and nearly all its contents somehow found their way onto the fabric-covered chair. Of course they did, I think to myself.

My daughter is just standing next to the chair, almost as if nothing has happened.

“Zoe!” I grumble out loud as I grab the dish rag. “This is a big spill! Why –” I trail off. I want to ask her why she didn’t say something, but of course she did say something. I want to ask why the tone of her voice wasn’t laced with more urgency when she announced the spill to me. In my mind in this moment, the spill of an entire bowl of cereal onto a fabric chair on a morning where we have to rush out the door is something of an urgent situation. I want to ask all of these “why” questions in a tone that is unkind.

But I am stopped as I stare at the Cheerios on the chair.

It has started out as this kind of day, but it doesn’t have to be this kind of day, I think to myself.

I have to fight the parts of me that want to make a bowlful of Cheerios spilled onto a chair a much bigger deal than they are.


We are deep in the throes of potty training my two-year-old son. Without shame we have chosen to use candy to bribe him for each successful trip to the bathroom. We learned the first time around with my older daughter that sugar is an incredibly useful tool to be used to parental advantage.

Both of my older children are staring upward as I open the treat cupboard, the one that is intentionally well out of their reach, to grab an M&M or two after one such successful run. Suddenly, my hand slips and I bump the bag, sending the remainder of the candies crashing to the floor. Dinnertime is near, but the mantra from earlier in the day comes back to me:

It started out as this kind of day, but it doesn’t have to be this kind of day.

The M&Ms had fallen from such a height that it reminded me of raindrops, so I start singing the first song that comes to mind:

It’s raining M&Ms, hallelujah, it’s raining M&Ms, hallelujah…” I belt out, recreating The Weather Girls’ 1983 classic It’s Raining Men.

My kids’ mouths hang open for half a second before starting to laugh, almost as if waiting for permission. They aren’t used to a kitchen spill producing a reaction like this from their harried mom. No, no; this is a much more delightful reaction than the one that can involve grumbling, grimacing and setting my jaw against saying the words that are chomping at the bit to spill forth from my mouth.

As I continue to sing and scoop up M&Ms from the tile floor, they join in, giggling and singing. Granted, a spill of M&Ms is quite a bit more delightful than a soggy cereal spill, but I want to freeze this moment in my mind. We just experienced an interruption, a mess that will need to be cleaned up, and yet we are smiling, dancing and giggling.

It started out as this kind of spill, but it doesn’t have to be this kind of spill.


Weeks later, I am rocking my oldest to sleep. She has started her second week of school, and after a day without naps, she has asked me to do this. These are my favorite kinds of bedtime snuggles – when they are too tired to really fight sleep with much vigor, and lie exhaustedly still as I rock. I sing and run my fingers through her hair as her eyelids surrender slowly to the end of the day. I reach deep into the memory vault and picture her pulling herself to standing as a baby; running from room to room giggling as a two-year-old; singing from the top of her lungs while sitting on the potty at three. I pull her up to cradle her as I used to. How is it that she is now almost five? How is it that we are now here? My mind breaks into achy prayers as the sudden rush of guilt and fear fills me: I am messing this all up. Somehow, all these memories of the smaller version of her make me feel the weight of motherhood even more. I could have been more kind, more patient, more inviting, more encouraging, more playful, more, more, more. I can’t live up to my own standard of what it looks like to be the best mom for her. The more I fret over it, the worse it seems to get.

It started out as this kind of memory, but it doesn’t have to be this kind of memory.

It would be easy to dwell here, in the muck of failure and fear, to let my experience of motherhood be defined by what I haven’t done or wish I had done differently. But that’s a pretty awful place to build memories. So as I ask God to protect her from my failures, I also lay this moment at his feet. It doesn’t have to be this kind of moment; I don’t want it to be this kind of moment.

“I’m messing it up, Daddy…fix it.”

The fear of failure gives way to delight as I’m reminded of the girl who gives “rainbow kisses” (one kiss on the left cheek, forehead and right cheek to form the arc).

This same girl cannot resist breaking into song even in the middle of Trader Joe’s (seriously – 20 whole minutes of near constant song during our last trip there).

She has a strong desire to lead which, when used well, is amazing to watch.

She gives her brother the owl sticker she got at school as soon as she walks out the classroom door…she’s been thinking of him.

She stood up for a classmate who was told he was ugly – she said “No he’s not! Don’t say that!”

Somehow, what started out as darkness becomes light, what started out as burden becomes delight, ashes are exchanged for beauty, and I am invited to rest in the witnessing of failures turned upside down.

It only started out as failure. It never has to finish that way.

*This post was originally published on the author’s blog. 

So God Made a Mother book by Leslie Means

If you liked this, you'll love our new book, SO GOD MADE A MOTHER available for pre-order now!

Pre-Order Now

Cat Gordon

Cat Gordon is an occasional writer, wife to a husband who leaves clothes on the floor but also folds laundry, and mom to three kids who can be found hitting, pinching, kissing and hugging each other all within a three-minute span. If she loves anyone well, it's because of Jesus. A born & raised Michigan gal trying to make sense of an unexpected life in So Cal, you can find her essays at Coffee + Crumbs and among other places. She blogs at The Cathartic Blend, and you can follow her on Instagram and Facebook @thecatharticblend, and on Twitter @catharticblend.

God Gave Him Bigger Feelings

In: Kids, Motherhood
Little boy on playground, color photo

He came home from school last week and asked, “Why do I get so angry but my friends never do? Why am I not the same?” And it broke me. Because he is passionate and intelligent and kind and intuitive and beautiful. He didn’t always seem different. We never paid attention to how he would line everything up in play. And we would laugh it off as a quirk when he would organize everything dependent upon shape, size, and color. He was stubborn, sure, but so am I. And then COVID happened, and we attributed the lack of social skills...

Keep Reading

We Have a Big Family and Wouldn’t Change a Thing

In: Kids, Motherhood
Four children in front of Christmas tree, color photo

I have just had my fourth baby. A baby who wasn’t expected but very much wanted and very much loved from the moment we found out. When we told people we were expecting, the response was underwhelming. The stream of intrusive questions would then ensue:  You already have your hands full, how will you cope with four? You’ll need a bigger car! Where will they all sleep? Don’t you own a TV? You know how babies are made right? People seemed to have such a strong opinion about me having a fourth child. RELATED: We Had a Lot of Kids...

Keep Reading

As a Mom I’m Far From Perfect, But I Hope You Remember the Joy

In: Kids, Motherhood
Happy mother and daughter on the beach

Sometimes, I think about the future when you are grown and I am gone. When all that’s left of me are photographs and memories. I know what the photographs will show. I took most of them, after all. But the memories I’m less sure of. I wonder what will stick with you after all that time. How will you remember me? One day, your grandkids will ask you about me. What will you say? Will you tell them I was always distracted? Will you remember that I looked at my phone too much? Will you tell them I didn’t play...

Keep Reading

Being a Daycare Mom Can Be So Hard

In: Kids, Living, Motherhood
Woman holding boy on couch, black-and-white photo

Dear daycare mom,  I know it’s hard.  To get yourself up before them, to make lunches, to pack the bags, to get yourself ready.  To go into their rooms, where they are peacefully sleeping, and turn the lights on.  To struggle to get them breakfast, get them dressed, and get them out the door.  I know it’s hard.  To have a morning rush when all you want to do is snuggle up on the couch and ease into your day.  RELATED: When a Mom is Late To Work To feel like you are missing out on their childhood at times...

Keep Reading

The PB&J that Saved the Day

In: Kids, Motherhood
Table with three plates of PB&J sandwiches, color photo

It was one of those days.  One of those days when your pants are too tight, you wake up with a headache, and the kids’ rooms are disasters at 8 a.m. It was one of those days when I had to physically go into Target for our groceries since I didn’t have time to wait for pickup—I think that alone should sum up exactly the kind of day it was.  The kids were hangry. The toddler was, well, toddler-y. RELATED: Toddlers Are Human Too—And Sometimes They Just Need Grace Two minutes into our shopping trip, she had kicked her light-up rain...

Keep Reading

One Day He’ll Love Another Woman More than He Loves Me

In: Kids, Motherhood
Mother holding baby, color photo

To Benjamin, my 16-month-old son, I am everything. I am the first person that boy looks for when he wakes up in the morning and the last person he wants before he goes to bed. If he is in a room full of people he loves and I am not there, he will search for me.  If he has a problem, mommy is the solution. I am the answer to his cries. I feel confident in saying that I am the most important person in that little boy’s little world. I love it. It is an honor and a privilege...

Keep Reading

To My Sister, Thank You For Being the Best Aunt To My Kids

In: Kids, Motherhood
Aunt with three young kids

“Do you have the kids’ basketball schedule yet?” you texted the other day. I sent back a screenshot of the calendar, and within an hour you responded telling me which game you’d be coming to. It was a simple exchange, but I was overwhelmed with gratitude for your love for my kids in that moment. It’s something I think often but don’t say nearly enough: thank you for being such an amazing aunt. Truly.  I know it’s not always convenient. You live three hours away and have a busy, full life of your own—but still, you show up for your niece and nephews...

Keep Reading

In Defense of the Stubborn Child

In: Kids, Motherhood
Little boy hanging over dock, color photo

“Lamp. Lamp. Laaaaamp,” my 2-year-old son screamed while stomping his feet. Tears were running down his face and snot was dripping dangerously close to his mouth. I put on what I hoped would be a soothing, motherly tone, “Okay, just calm down.” While trying to maintain eye contact, I slowly reached toward the tissue box. This must be what the greats like Jeff Corwin, Steve Irwin, or the Kratt brothers feel like when facing a volatile animal in the wild. The sound of a tissue being pulled from the box caused the crying to stop abruptly. His eyes flitted toward...

Keep Reading

Dear Stepdaughter, You Aren’t “Mine” but I Love You as My Own

In: Kids, Motherhood
Mother and daughter hug

First off, I love you. I wasn’t there the day you were born or when you got your first tooth. I wasn’t there when you took your first steps or learned to pee in the potty. But, I have loved you since the day we met, and I’ve been there for every moment since. I’ve given you baths and eventually, taught you how to shower on your own. I’ve brushed your hair, clipped your nails, and taken care of you when you’re sick. I’ve tucked you into bed and kissed you goodnight, held you when you’re sad, chased away your...

Keep Reading

I Was Meant to Be a Boy Mom

In: Kids, Motherhood
Mother and three boys, black-and-white photo

When you’re a little girl, you dream of the day you can pass all your Barbies and dolls on to your daughter and continue that same form of make-believe, to play dress up, do their hair, and go shopping with . . . at least I did.  You grow up, fall in love, get married, and decide to start a family and all those same emotions come rushing back about all you’ll do with your baby girl. You cut open that cake and the blue frosting peeks through, and you’re so excited that you forget all those girl dreams. You...

Keep Reading