For as long as I can remember, I’ve been a perfectionist. I’ve struggled with accepting myself as good enough, with accepting my identity in Christ. And now, as a mother of two young kids, I have to wrestle with how to combat this perfectionism in my parenting and in the example I set for them. 

I can trace my perfectionism back to when I was in fourth grade. I wore gold-rimmed glasses and a plaid jumper, part of our school uniform. Our classroom smelled like chalk dust, pencil shavings, and old metal desks. It was Friday afternoon, and the sun poured in from the large windows. Our 14-person class buzzed with whispers and murmurs.

“Hush!” said Mrs. Sterling, shaking her gray-topped head. “These are your report cards. They are in order, so just take the top one and pass the pile back.” 

Several classmates peeked at the report cards, and the gossip swept across the room like wildfire. 

“Poor Bethany, she’s the only girl who didn’t get straight As!” Jennifer (not her real name) croaked, her blonde bob bouncing as she peeked back at me as if to say, “I hope you heard that.” 

RELATED: Dear Daughter, Do Not Be Perfect

Her mocking tone set off my 10-year-old-sized endocrine system. Heart pumping, fists balled. That’s it! I’m never going to let her say that again! I’m going to get straight As from now on.

I spent my evenings on a wooden dining-room chair, underneath the harsh overhead lights, doing math equations or practicing spelling words until my butt was sore and my eyes were squinty. 

My struggle for perfection continued through my high school years and beyond. At my small liberal arts college, I met other perfectionists. We spent our nights and weekends chained to library chairs, noses to books, lungs barely exhaling beneath the quiet roar of pages turning, fingers typing, brains churning.

Now as a wife and mother, my perfectionism comes out in different ways.

I obsess over the cleanliness (or lack of cleanliness) of our home whenever guests come to visit. I feel guilty if I haven’t spent enough alone time with my husband. I feel guilty when my toddler watches too much TV or doesn’t eat enough veggies or when I order pizza for dinner instead of cooking a meal. I read my toddler at least 10 books a day and bristle with pride when the doctor tells me his vocabulary is advanced for his age. 

When I had just one kid, at the end of the day I felt like I was doing a pretty good job as a parent. I was doing enough. But now I have a 2-year-old boy and a 2-month-old girl. I get to the end of the day and feel like I’ve barely survived some days

I often feel like my parenting is just putting out one fire after another. Changing one diaper, then another. Sweeping up crushed Goldfish crackers then scrubbing green crayon off the walls. I know that my parenting is supposed to be purposeful, building the character of my kids. But a lot of days, it feels like I’m just chasing my tail, or rather, chasing my toddler and nursing my baby. 

RELATED: God Doesn’t Ask Me To Be a Perfect Mom; He Asks Me To Point My Kids to a Perfect Savior

One day, I was completely exhausted, trying to do it all. I plopped down on the couch and prayed, “God, I don’t know how to do this. I can’t do this.” I was then reminded of something important.

The thing Jesus says is the most important thing: love God and love people. 

I had a eureka moment. I realized that was all God was calling me to do as a parent, to train up my kids to love God and to love others. All the small thingsthe books and grades, the nutrition and exercise, the messes and discipline strugglesdon’t matter that much. It’s not that they don’t matter at all, but they aren’t the main thing. 

I felt a weight lift off me. “God, help me to raise my kids to love you and to love others,” I prayed. I pray that prayer every day now. I take deep breaths and pray it when I feel overwhelmed, when I feel perfectionism trying to take over. 

I still struggle daily with perfectionism. But now, I’m beginning to find rest in focusing my life and my parenting on that one truth. 

So God Made a Mother book by Leslie Means

If you liked this, you'll love our book, SO GOD MADE A MOTHER available now!

Order Now

Check out our new Keepsake Companion Journal that pairs with our So God Made a Mother book!

Order Now
So God Made a Mother's Story Keepsake Journal

Bethany Jarmul

Bethany Jarmul is a writer and work-from-home mom. She lives in Pittsburgh with her husband and two young kids.

At the End of Your Life, This is What Will Matter to Your Children

In: Marriage
At the End of Your Life, This is What Will Matter to Your Children

The death of George HW Bush has caused me to reflect on what really matters to my children and others at the end of life. As I was watching the eulogy given by his son George W Bush, I made a mental note of what actually mattered to George W at the end of his father’s life and what things had made him a better, well-adjusted adult. His father played games with them, had fun with them, had family dinners with them, and showed them integrity and love for others. But the thing that seemed to leave the biggest impression...

Keep Reading

I Pray I’m Raising Kids Who Love Jesus

In: Faith, Kids, Motherhood
Mother sharing milkshake with child, color photo

I used to worry I might be feeding my kids too much junk food. I’d wonder, did we start their college funds early enough? Am I allowing too much screen time? Am I giving them enough outside play? Did they have enough tummy time? Should I have done baby-led weaning vs. purées? Did I breastfeed them long enough? Did I sing the right songs while they were in the womb? Then something happened. I let go of the expectations the world had for me as a mother and how I should or shouldn’t raise my kids. I let go of...

Keep Reading

To the Mom Trying to Do It All, You’re In God’s Way

In: Faith, Motherhood
To the Mom Trying to Do It All, You're In God's Way

I’m a laid-back perfectionist. Seriously, it’s a thing. I am completely at peace going out in public looking like I just got electrocuted, in the shower, fully clothed, while cutting my hair. But I won’t even attempt (fill in the blank) if there’s even a small chance of failure. I don’t know if that’s being a perfectionist or just a coward. So when I got married, I realized pretty quickly I wasn’t the perfect wife. It was shocking to no one but me. Much to my dismay, I wasn’t as good of a cook or hostess or decorator or housekeeper as I thought I’d...

Keep Reading