Editor’s note: contains movie spoilers
I really wanted to see Tully.
The first trailer I saw for the upcoming Charlize Theron movie, marketed as a raw and unfiltered look at mom life, made me tear up. The previews depict Theron’s character, Marlo, as an everyday exhausted mom—struggling to nurse a newborn, care for her older children and still spend time with her husband.
Enter Tully, a night nanny gifted to Marlo by a friend. Tully arrives saying she is there to help (every mom’s dream). She is happy to get up with baby at night and pamper Marlo by day. Now there’s a movie for moms, I thought. One that validates how hard the daily grind can really get. Buy me a ticket.
Unfortunately, I was mislead.
Because Tully features a plot twist. Not only does the film include a scene in which Tully gets intimate with Marlo’s husband (and under Marlo’s direction) it gets worse.
Near the film’s end, after Marlo winds up in the hospital following a car accident, a doctor diagnoses her with postpartum depression. And, it is revealed her beloved Tully is not real. She is a hallucination representing Marlo’s younger self. Yes, really.
Plot twists are fine in, say, an M. Night Shyamalan film or Fight Club, but this is a movie being marketed as mirroring a realistic motherhood experience. For months, the advertising has attracted moms seeking a dose of all the feels. In my mom groups, friends set up events to go see it. These are women interested in fun and a stress-free night out, some of whom are even struggling with actual postpartum depression.
As a mom who experienced severe anxiety during my first pregnancy and subsequent mild depression, I am disappointed. I feel betrayed by the makers of Tully. I feel slighted. For starters, Tully needs to come with a trigger warning. Had I gone to see the movie based on its advertising, I would have left shaken. I intentionally shy away from movies related to mental illness. Women with a history of postpartum mental health issues deserve at least a fair warning. Not to mention those currently suffering. Can you imagine going to the movie thinking it might help your PPD? Or leaving thinking a symptom of the disorder is imaginary friends? Yes, postpartum psychosis, a more serious disorder, can cause hallucinations, but Tully in no way depicts this disorder or even mentions it.
Diablo Cody, the writer and director of Tully, did not make a movie for mothers. She made a movie for awards, critical acclaim and in my opinion, attention. The irresponsible marketing will no doubt drive many moms to theaters for the film’s May 4 opening. Sadly, many will come out feeling cheated or worse.
The filmmakers may think they captured a true-to-life experience. But it isn’t mine.
You might also want to read:
Want more stories of love, family, and faith from the heart of every home, delivered straight to you? Sign up here!