Written By:  Leslie Means

I have a secret.

I started making this secret chocolate chip cookie recipe when I was a young girl. I’ve made lots and LOTS of batches.

Maybe more.

This recipe has been a fan favorite for many years. I’ve made it for birthday parties, family gatherings, company picnics and the like. I’ve heard people say, “Leslie, what is in your cookie recipe? It’s SO good.”

And I tell them.

“It’s a few of my mom’s secret ingredients that make these bad boys so tasty.”

Then a few years ago my sister, Lindsay shared the REAL secret.

“Um, Les – that recipe mom uses is the same dang recipe on the back of the chocolate chip cookie bag. You can just tell people you got it from “Nestley – a toll-housey”  (Insert sarcastic accent).

What? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! That can’t be.

It was.

The. Exact. Same. Recipe.

Crushed, I called mom to ask her if my sister spoke the truth.

“Yes, Leslie,” she says. “But – there are a few things that I use that makes the recipe unique.”

She’s right. Our recipe calls for Crisco. NOT butter. I’m not a fan of flat, crunchy cookies. These bad boys will never be flat.

We have other special additions too. Having made them so many times, I can tell you before the cookies are baked whether or not they will be good. Here’s a few special touches we add to the batch.

*Use REAL vanilla. Nothing imitation.

*Use a HUGE cookie scoop.

*Use Kosher salt instead of table salt.

*Place your cookies on a silver, jelly roll pan. (I seriously think other cookie sheets hamper with the baking process.)

*Bake only about 8-10 minutes on 375. Take your cookies out a few minutes before they are fully cooked; let them finish baking on the cookie sheet.

*ONLY use Nestle real semi-sweet chocolate chips. They are the best for these guys.

*Pop them in the fridge or (my favorite) the freezer. I think they’re best cold.

*Use the entire bag of chocolate chips and eliminate the nuts. (That’s my addition.) 

*Use fresh eggs. (This is easy for me as mom and dad and my sister, Lindsay have chickens. I’m likely to have fresh eggs throughout the year.) 

If you’re a butter-in-your-cookie fan, you might not like the Crisco one as well. (AKA – my sister, Lindsay who crushed my heart by telling me it’s not a secret recipe.)

HOWEVER, throughout the years I’ve have 100’s of people tell me how much they loved my cookies. And my biggest critics; Kyle, my girls and my dad?

They love them.

That’s pretty much all that matters anyway. 😉

Leslie’s Secret Ingredient Chocolate Chip Cookies! 

(AKA – Nestle Toll House with a few additions)

1. 1 tsp. REAL vanilla

2. 1 tsp. Kosher Salt

3. 1 bag (usually about 3 cups) Nestle Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips

4. 1 tsp. baking soda (Make sure this one is fresh, too.)

5. 3/4 cup granulated sugar

6. 1 cup Crisco

7. 3/4 cup packed brown sugar

8. 2 eggs (It’s fun to have fresh, chicken eggs. Make sure you check to see if  there is a chick hanging out in one of them before used! Yes. You can stop gagging now).

9. 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour

Preheat oven to 375 degrees

Combine flour, baking soda and salt in small bowl. Set aside.

Beat butter, granulated sugar, brown sugar and vanilla in large mixer bowl until creamy. Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Gradually beat in flour mixture. Stir in morsels and (optional) nuts.

Use large cookie scoop. Place dough on non-greased cookie sheet (again, I use a silver jelly roll pan). I can hold 12 cookies on one pan comfortably.

Bake until just about finished; 8-10 minutes. Take out of oven and leave cookies on sheet to continue baking for 1-2 minutes.

Move to wire racks to cool. Place in freezer/fridge in air-tight containers once cooled for best taste!

Do you have any “secret” recipes? We want to know your favorites!!

 

So God Made a Mother book by Leslie Means

If you liked this, you'll love our book, SO GOD MADE A MOTHER available now!

Order Now

Check out our new Keepsake Companion Journal that pairs with our So God Made a Mother book!

Order Now
So God Made a Mother's Story Keepsake Journal

Leslie Means

Leslie is the founder and owner of Her View From Home.com. She is also a former news anchor, published children’s book author, weekly columnist, and has several published short stories as well. She is married to a very patient man. Together they have three fantastic kids.  When she’s not sharing too much personal information online and in the newspaper – you’ll find Leslie somewhere in Nebraska hanging out with family and friends. There’s also a 75% chance at any given time, you’ll spot her in the aisles at Target.

Sweet & Crunchy Valentine’s Snack Mix

In: Kitchen, Living
Valentine's Day snack mix by a white bowl

There is something about this time year that makes me hungry for a good snack mix. Maybe it’s the dull, grey weather. And, the fact that what I would really like to do is stay in my pajamas, on the couch with a good book or movie, and eat snack mix ALL day Long! With tea. Or better yet—wine. Wine goes with snack mix, doesn’t it?  I really just love all the different flavors, textures, colors, and the fact that I can almost make a healthy meal out of this stuff. Protein —you betcha. Whole grains—of course! Fruit—yes. M&Ms—they are...

Keep Reading

Dear Son, Our Work Together Isn’t Done Yet

In: Kids, Kitchen, Motherhood, Teen, Tween
Dear Son, Our Work Together Isn't Done Yet www.herviewfromhome.com

I woke up early to come wake you up. Even though you don’t need me to. Even though you’re capable of waking up on your own to your own alarm clock in your own room. Every day you become more independent and every day I’m wondering what my role is in your life. My motherhood job description keeps changing and I’m doing my best to keep up and change accordingly. So I woke up to wake you up so we could spend some early morning moments as just the two of us, the way it used to be before all...

Keep Reading

The Mexican Brownie Disaster (Recipe Inside!)

In: Kitchen, Recipe Journal
The Mexican Brownie Disaster (Recipe Inside!) www.herviewfromhome.com

Even as a teenage I remember browsing through my mom’s cookbooks, marking recipes that piqued my interest, but rarely seeing any through to fruition. In part, this was due to my mother’s love-hate relationship with the kitchen. Love because she believed strongly in family dinnertime and was happy to open our home and table to guests. Hate because she didn’t actually enjoy cooking and certainly wasn’t looking for opportunities to mix, chop, roast, or blend more than absolutely necessary. Market Day Chicken Stir Fry was a go-to and family favorite. I, on the other hand, thought it might be exciting...

Keep Reading

Organize Your Pantry in 10 Easy Steps

In: Kitchen, Style
Organize Your Pantry in 10 Easy Steps www.herviewfromhome.com

Having an unorganized pantry was causing me stress. Every time I opened it, it bothered me. And, if your household is anything like mine, the door to the pantry gets opened A LOT, everyday! There was no better time than after the holidays and the start of a new year: I was going to get it organized, no matter what.  I assessed the project for quite some time, researching, and shopping, but I didn’t want it to look mismatched and like I had just thrown things together. I wanted it legit, organized like a pro. We don’t have a very...

Keep Reading

I Used to Want to Change the World. Now I Just Want a Cookie.

In: Health, Healthy Living, Kitchen
I Used to Want to Change the World. Now I Just Want a Cookie. www.herviewfromhome.com

I’m on the seventh day of a month-long highly restrictive diet to try to deal with some health issues I’ve been having. I want to get that information out of the way up front, just in case this post comes across a little “hangry.” As I’ve been dealing with cutting things from my diet and adding in new things to try to figure out why I’m having my current health issues, it has occurred to me how much time I’ve had to spend thinking about food that I used to spend being productive. It’s not just the actual food prep...

Keep Reading

If We Can’t Have Jack Back from ‘This is Us’ At least We Can Put His Face on Our Crock-Pots

In: Humor, Kitchen
If We Can't Have Jack Back from 'This is Us' At least We Can Put His Face on Our Crock-Pots www.herviewfromhome.com

Business owners are smart. Especially Etsy shop owners who see an opportunity—like capitalizing on the latest American obsession. So here it is. For “This is Us” fans (hahaha—like there are people out there who AREN’T “This is Us” fans), Etsy shops are now offering Crock-Pot decals of phrases like “Unplug Me, Jack” and also images of his beautiful face. This is how we can bring him back, girls. And also keep our Crock-Pots. Kidding! Crock-Pot was very quick to defend their product after America’s sobfest 2018, saying in a statement: Crock-Pot understands the concerns brought up by last night’s episode...

Keep Reading

Chocolate Pot de Crème

In: Featured, Kitchen

Chocolate and romance go hand in hand and with Valentine’s Day around the bend, why not have a beautifully simple and romantic dessert on the menu? With Valentine’s Day falling on a Saturday, it might be a little more difficult to get those reservations to go out to eat to celebrate. If you end up staying home, why not have an easy, romantic dessert to finish your meal? Made in a blender or food processor and refrigerated, this recipe is easy to make and the result can be a beautiful and elegant dessert that will put the perfect cap on...

Keep Reading

Easy Crockpot Chicken Tacos

In: Kitchen
Easy Crockpot Chicken Tacos www.herviewfromhome.com

Since fall is quickly coming upon us, we wanted to do a simple crock-pot meal. Just place the ingredients in to the crock-pot and forget it until it is time to eat! Not only is it easy, it also scales up easily to serve anywhere from a single family to a large party, so this is perfect for those busy fall weekends. This chicken crockpot meal has a Mexican twist to it. It is made even easier with the ability to use frozen chicken and just let it cook! The chicken ends up tender and juicy, perfect for use on tacos,...

Keep Reading

Creamy Chicken and Rice Soup

In: Featured, Kitchen

Written By:  Rachel Gnagy @ Inscribed Photography & Design (recipe originally from here) One of my favorite ‘girly’ meals to make is soup served in bread bowls. I love getting the Broccoli Cheese soup at Quizno’s (it’s healthy because it has broccoli, right?) and Panera’s Cream of Chicken & Wild Rice soup. YUM. So when I saw a recipe on Pinterest for creamy chicken and rice soup, I thought I would give it a try! You will need: 1 Tablespoon of olive oil 2-3 carrots, sliced 2 cloves of garlic, minced 5 cups of chicken stock 1 cup of cooked chicken,...

Keep Reading

Chicken Cordon Bleu for Two

In: Featured, Kitchen

Written By:  Rachel @ Inscribed Photography (Recipe originally from here) Valentine’s Day is coming up and with that in mind I wanted to bring you an easy, delicious meal for you and your special man. This recipe is by far the easiest Chicken Cordon Bleu recipe and it is super yummy too! Pair it with some steamed veggies on the side and something chocolatey for dessert and you’re all set for a romantic dinner for two. For the chicken, you will need: 2 chicken breasts, cut in half lengthwise 8 slices of deli ham 8 slices of Swiss cheese 1...

Keep Reading