Our kitchen filled with the rich aroma of chicken soup simmering atop the stove, steam rising from the pot of sliced carrots and celery, whole onions, and stewing chicken. I inhaled the scent of love that chicken soup represents. 

Although it had long been a staple of our Jewish family life, no chicken soup had been made in our kitchen for the previous six years. We’d enjoyed this soup at the homes of family, ordered it in restaurants, eaten take-out versions at our table. But until today, my husband Bob insisted that chicken soup could not be made in our kitchen. 

Iconic Jewish soul food for generations, this simple soup goes back to shtetls and towns in the “old countries” of Russia, Poland, and Ukraine, where its humble ingredients could be found in communities afflicted by poverty and persecution. Chicken soup is said to have healing properties; many a Jewish mother has boiled up a batch of this elixir to soothe a sick child or mend a broken heart.

Throughout our 30-year marriage, Bob had always made the chicken soup. Starting with a family recipe, he’d experimented with variations that included celery root, rutabaga, parsnips, and turnips, seeking the blend that created the flavorful broth he would strain through cheesecloth to achieve the golden clarity of the perfect soup. Making chicken soup connected Bob to his Russian grandmother, and to all the Jewish people. His perfected recipe resided only in his head: Bob’s soup, beloved by all who attended our Passover Seders. 

New Year’s Day 2012 marked the last time Bob made chicken soup. A pediatrician, he’d been working at the hospital 12 straight days, and celebrated his time off by making soup. While the soup simmered on our stove that frigid day, we found our 23-year-old son, Benjamin, lifeless in his bed upstairs. Trauma burned every sensory detail of that moment into our brains, creating powerful triggers for unwanted memories. For Bob, the smell of boiling chicken soup became indelibly linked to the loss of our precious son; he could never make his soup again.

We stopped hosting Passover Seders and started our grief journeys, often parallel but rarely converging, as we each mourned Benjamin in our own ways. I longed to reminisce about our son together, but he found that intolerable. Creating symbols to comfort myself and honor Benjamin’s memory, I made quilts, planted trees, painted stones to leave at his grave, treasured objects he’d left behind. This was not Bob’s way; seeing Benjamin’s photos or possessions set off unbearable pain and avoidance. I hoped that someday Bob could find healing symbols of his own.

As Passover 2018 approached, I planned meals and made sure we had plenty of matzah. Chicken soup was not on the menu. We sat in our kitchen, discussing what I’d make.

“Did you buy farfel?” Bob asked. Farfel is like crumbled matzah, often eaten in chicken soup.

“No . . .” I said. “But we don’t have any soup to put it in. Would you like me to make chicken soup?”  This was an offer I’d made many times, always rejected.

“Well . . .” he said, “I don’t know.” 

I held my breath; were we turning a momentous corner?

“Could you?” he asked, his green eyes looking into mine.

I chose my words carefully. “I’d be happy to make it, as long as it’s OK with you.”

“OK,” he said, exhaling. “Maybe you could look online at different Jewish chicken soup recipes, kind of make it your own. It doesn’t have to be my soup.”

“But if I am going to make it, we need to buy the ingredients today. The store will be closed for Easter tomorrow. Shall I go?”

“No, I’ll go,” he said, surprising me again.

When Bob returned with the soup ingredients, we reviewed his recipe and decided I’d make the soup while he was at the gym Sunday morning. 

As he left, Bob turned the vent fan above the stove on “high”. I’d wondered whether an emotional dam might break when he came home to the smell, but it was more like a slow thaw. I’d made the soup and simmered it for two hours, just as he’d instructed; now it was time to remove the cooked vegetables and boil fresh ones in the broth. Bob lifted the lid off the pot and gave it a stir. Hoping to minimize his pain, I hesitated to ask questions, but I had to know, “Do you think it’s done?”

“It looks like there’s not enough broth,” he said, frowning. “I forgot, sometimes stewing chickens take longer to get done. Add more water, cook it for another hour.” 

Bob sat reading in the next room while I finished the soup. That night, we shared a dinner of chicken soup with matzah balls, farfel, and parsley. Neither of us mentioned the progress this represented; we both knew what this soup meant. We didn’t reminisce about Benjamin, but for now, this meal was miracle enough. Another door had opened in our long process of mutual healing, in the separation of memory from the darkness of grief. And my soup wasn’t bad.

You may also like: 

This is Grief

Learning to Live With the Scars of Grief

It’s OK to Just Listen

Want more stories of love, family, and faith from the heart of every home, delivered straight to you? Sign up here!

So God Made a Mother book by Leslie Means

If you liked this, you'll love our new book, SO GOD MADE A MOTHER available now!

Order Now

Lucinda Cummings

Lucinda Cummings is a writer, mother, and clinical psychologist who lives in Minneapolis. Her work has appeared previously in mamazine and is forthcoming in the anthology, She's Got This. She is seeking a publisher for her book length memoir on finding home.

Growing Slowly around the Grief of Losing Your Mom

In: Grief, Loss
Sad woman sitting on couch with folded arms

Everyone has heard about the five stages of grief: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. Society often assumes the stages of grief happen in order, but those who encounter grief know that’s not true. Undergoing grief can feel like riding a rollercoaster blindfolded—disorienting and chaotic. There are numerous ups, downs, and twists you wouldn’t anticipate. Grief is like an ocean. When waves come crashing, it feels like you’re being swept away. Regardless of their size, waves are always rough. Despite everything, you also get pushed forward to the shore after every wave. Sometimes, you may feel like you are drowning...

Keep Reading

The Shattering Grief of Suicide

In: Grief, Living, Loss
Sad person sitting in darkened hallway, black and white image

Navigating through my second Christmas without my dad, the weight of grief seemed even heavier this year. In fact, everything felt and looked different to me. As I unwrapped the ornaments and cards he gave me over the years, a tidal wave of madness and sadness engulfed me. I know many feel sadness and grieve during these times, but let me just say . . . suicide is a different type of grief. My vibrant, happy, physically fit dad committed suicide on April 30th, 2022. There, I said it. In the aftermath, a myriad of emotions consumed me. One perplexing...

Keep Reading

Dear Dad, Maybe You’re the Bird

In: Grief, Loss
Young girl sitting on father's lap, older color photo

Maybe you’re the bird. The one I see outside my door. The one who flies so low it seems you’re somehow weighted down. Like you’re carrying more than just yourself. Like you’re carrying a message. Just for me. Maybe you’re the rain. The sound I hear that reminds me so much of home. Of you. Of driving in your car as a little girl when you looked over and asked my opinion about everything. When you made someone so small feel so very big. RELATED: Dad Left a Legacy in Fried Green Tomatoes Maybe you’re the butterfly. The one I...

Keep Reading

I Hope You Never Know What it’s Like to Forget Who You Are

In: Grief, Living, Loss
Woman staring at camera, black-and-white photo

I write best when I’m passionate. It’s always been my release. But lately, I’ve struggled to write. I’ve struggled to find purpose in my words. It’s all been twisted and choppy, not a bit poetic or beautiful. These feelings are what the struggles of loss, parenting, work, and marriage push against. It’s finding yourself over and over again and trying to make sense of the senseless. It leaves you questioning most things and leaves you feeling broken with no idea how to put yourself or others back together. I hope you never know. I hope you never know what it’s...

Keep Reading

I Don’t Know How to Live Without My Sister, But I Must

In: Grief
Sisters smiling in posed color photo

I’ve spent a year of my life living in a haze. Holding my breath, afraid to exhale. Focusing on staying in this frozen moment where there is no reality. I pressed the pause button. Pumped the brakes. I’ll stay right here and wait for my life, life as I knew it, life as I loved it, to come back around. Where there is no future to mourn, thinking about the way it should have been and no torturous past to remember, recalling the horror of that day. The special occasions that will come are now outlined in sadness. Wait, she’s...

Keep Reading

6 Ways to Be a Friend to Someone Grieving

In: Friendship, Grief, Loss
Friends hugging

Grief can truly be such a lonely experience after you lose a loved one. The loneliness isn’t necessarily because you don’t have anyone around you. It’s because only you had your relationship with the person who died, and it’s hard to find anyone to replace that. I have first-hand experience. My mom died recently and unexpectedly at the age of 62 and I at the age of 34, and it single-handedly has been one of the most painful experiences of my life. However, having support from family and friends will help you navigate this difficult time. Without it, the loneliness...

Keep Reading

These Final Gifts from My Mom Are Hard to Let Go

In: Grief, Loss
Little girls boots with worn toes, color photo

My daughter wobbled toward me in silver, square-toed go-go boots, one heel dislodged and flopping against our hallway’s faux wood floor. On her opposite foot, a striped sock peaked curiously through the growing toe hole. “Mama,” she said. Her tiny voice raised another octave, “My shoe!” I sighed, then sat on the floor. Waves of grief washed over me as I contemplated what kind of glue might capably reconstruct the shoe’s sole. Elmer’s glue? Textile glue? Maybe Krazy Glue? I knew the boots should just go into the bin. And yet, they—along with a vibrant, overbearing cat dress that would...

Keep Reading

A Daughter Is Never Ready To Let Her Dad Go

In: Grief, Loss
Grown daughter hugging older man

I wasn’t ready to let you go. When I was a little girl, one of my greatest fears was that something would happen to my parents. If they had to go somewhere, I would nervously follow their route in my mind, mentally noting where they probably were and when they should be back home. If they hadn’t returned by the time I thought they should, my imagination would get the best of me as I pictured a thousand things that could have happened. But the day I sat having a late breakfast at my kitchen table and saw an ambulance...

Keep Reading

Memories of Mom Are Everywhere

In: Grief, Motherhood
Family campsite with bikes, tents, and totes, color photo

Two weeks after my daughter was born, my dad drove from Pennsylvania to our home in Florida to stay with me for the week. I was nursing my daughter on the couch when my dad drug in four humongous plastic storage bins and staged them next to the Pack ‘N Play in the living room. The bins were full of my baby clothes, baby shower cards, a silver spoon, plastic and probably lead-infused rattles, and two cellophane balloons neatly folded. A time capsule of my babyhood. I thought of my mom’s hands being the last to touch these items. Had...

Keep Reading

Don’t Forget the Heartbroken Mothers

In: Grief, Loss, Motherhood
Woman sad sitting on couch

The loss I recently experienced hit differently than others I’ve experienced. I thought that with three kids already in tow, it wouldn’t ache quite this bad. But it has. I don’t know if it’s because I was further along or because my entire household was over-the-top giddy and excited for this precious new life to enter the world. Perhaps it was the trauma of how everything happened or because I actually gave birth to him and held him. RELATED: We Lost Our Baby at 17 Weeks Pregnant Attending my first appointment to confirm the loss was brutal. I was surrounded...

Keep Reading